Easy2Siksha Sample Papers
Lewis’s model beautifully explained what happened in many developing countries during
the 20th century.
Take the example of countries like China, Japan, or South Korea.
At first, they were mostly agricultural economies with vast rural populations. Over time,
as industries grew, millions of people migrated from villages to cities. This led to rapid
industrial growth, urbanization, and economic transformation — just as Lewis predicted.
Even today, countries like India are experiencing this transition.
Millions of people are moving from villages to towns, working in manufacturing,
services, and construction. The Lewis model helps us understand this journey.
Criticisms of the Lewis Model
No theory is perfect — and economists have pointed out a few limitations of Lewis’s
model. Let’s discuss them in simple terms:
1. Overestimation of Surplus Labour:
Lewis assumed there’s a large pool of surplus labour in agriculture. But in reality,
removing too many workers from farms can reduce food output.
2. Neglect of Rural Development:
The model focuses too much on industry and ignores the development of the
agricultural sector.
3. Assumption of Profit Reinvestment:
Lewis believed industrialists would reinvest all profits. But in real life, they might
spend on luxury goods or transfer profits abroad instead of reinvesting.
4. Constant Wage Assumption:
In practice, industrial wages often rise even before the surplus labour is fully
absorbed due to labour unions or government policies.
5. Urban Problems:
Rapid migration to cities can create problems like slums, unemployment, and
poverty — issues Lewis’s model doesn’t fully address.
Despite these criticisms, Lewis’s theory remains a milestone in development economics
because it provided a clear and logical explanation of how economies can grow by
transforming their structure.
Why Lewis’s Model Still Matters
Even decades later, the Lewis Model continues to guide policymakers and economists. It
reminds us that: